In Calabarzon, workers get first taste of wage cuts via two-tier wage system
PUBLISHED ON AUGUST 10, 2012
2nd of two, series on two-tier wage
1st of two, series on two-tier wage: From wage freeze to wage cuts: Aquino government pilots two-tier wage system
By MARYA SALAMAT
Calamba, LAGUNA – The two-tier wage system is being piloted since May this year in Region IV-A or Calabarzon (short for the provinces of Cavite, Laguna, Batangas, Rizal and Quezon). The region hosts nearly half of all approved or proclaimed export-oriented ecozones in the Philippines.
The new wage policy is laid down here through Wage Order No. 15. It sets the “floor wage” at P255 ($6.10) per day, an amount that is lower than the minimum wage rates in the three areas of the region. Minimum wages in the region range from P315 to P337 ($7.54 to $8.07).
The new “floor wage,” or the first and the mandatory wage tier, is reportedly effective up to 2016. It will change only when the poverty threshold for the region changes. The second tier, or the productivity-based part, is a P12.50 ($0.30) “conditional temporary productivity allowance.”
So, where are the pay hikes?
The wage order granted a range of pay hikes from P2 to P90 ($0.06 to $2.15), but only for workers earning less than P255 ($6.10). On the average, most Calabarzon workers earning less than P255 ($6.10) would get only P18 ($0.43), said the labor thinktank Ecumenical Institute of Labor Education and Research (EILER) in its study of Wage Order No. 15.
Members of Pamantik-KMU hold picket in front of NLRC in Laguna July 2012 (Photo by Marya Salamat / bulatlat.com)
Meanwhile, the minimum wage earners in Calabarzon get no mandatory increase in the latest wage order, EILER said.
Calabarzon workers can avail of the P12.50 ($0.30) on top of their “floor wage” or minimum wage, but this is a “conditional temporary productivity allowance,” subject to the formation and decision of a productivity committee.
Pamantik also scoffed at the amount. With the regional wage board putting a cap on the productivity-based pay, PAMANTIK said, it had also exposed the deception that this pay is ‘productivity-based.’ “Even if you work harder than ever, they have already put a cap on the increases you can get from the increased productivity,” Urgel said.
If the workers ever receive a conditional allowance, EILER said, it is excluded in computing the basic pay. It is, after all, just an “allowance,” like COLA.
Thus, the start of two-tier wage system in Calabarzon has brought the imposition of a lower “floor wage” than the current minimum wage. It freezes the current minimum wage rates, supposedly for five years. At the same time, it stipulated some increases but only to workers earning even lower than the newly prescribed “floor wage” of P255 ($6.10). The wording of the wage order is such that the floor wage of P255 ($6.10). seems to be the target wage rate to achieve.
Not only that, as the progressive labor center in Calabarzon revealed, the newly prescribed “floor wage” is even lower than the average wage being paid in violation of the minimum wage.
From low wage to lower wage
In an interview, leaders of PAMANTIK, the regional chapter of progressive labor center Kilusang Mayo Uno (KMU) in the area, disclosed that the prescribed minimum wages in the three areas of Calabarzon are hardly implemented correctly or on time. Usually, employers pay lower wages than the prescribed minimum.
Calabarzon workers demand regularization at the job in May Day rally. (Photo courtesy of Pamantik-KMU / bulatlat.com)
In the region’s 249 economic enclaves, some 70-percent of companies or “locators” do not follow the wage orders, Wenecito Urgel, secretary general of Pamantik, told Bulatlat.com.
“Most companies don’t pay the prescribed minimum wage but pay per output. In real life Southern Tagalog workers get P265 to P298 ($6.34 to $7.13), depending on where they work in the region,” said Urgel. (The minimum wage rates here range from P315 to P337 [$7.53 to $8.07.])
Southern Tagalog has a “growth corridor area,” an “emerging growth area,” and a “resource-based area.” All three have different minimum wage rates.
In the growth corridor area where minimum wages are highest at P337 ($8.07), the workers are paid only P298 ($7.13) per day, Urgel said. (Note that P298 [$7.13] is higher than the P255 [$6.10] “floor wage” set by the government in piloting the two-tier wage system.) Wages, both the prescribed minimum and actual amount being paid, are lower in other areas.
At times, “Companies start paying the minimum wage only when the worker has already worked for one year, to appease and forestall his or her demand to be regular,” Urgel said. (Legally, a worker should be considered as regular on the job after working six months.) Transnational corporations do this, Urgel said, also to avoid being slapped with cases by their workers.
But regularizing workers is often avoided by companies in Southern Tagalog, Urgel said. He added that workers get to be called regular only in unionized workplaces, after unions fought for it.
Wenecito Urgel, secretary-general of Pamantik-KMU, in a picket before Calamba NLRC, Jul 2012 (Photo by Marya Salamat / bulatlat.com)
Fixed-term contracts lasting up to three years prevail in the region, said Urgel. Contract renewal is conditional on performance. But then, because companies shirk paying the separation or retirement pay, after a while, most workers no longer get a new contract, Urgel added. He cited as example an electronics firm in Cavite, where only 20-percent of the 2,000 workforce are regular workers, and the rest are “regular for three years only.”
Last year’s wage order of P15 ($0.36) has not yet reached many of the workers in Calabarzon. Urgel said that usually, “it takes six months to a year before workers receive the wage hike.”
But with the advent of the two-tier wage system, Hermie Marasigan, chairman of Pamantik, asked: what will happen to workers?
Pamantik said the advent of two-tier wage system has only further attacked the concept and practice of paying the minimum wages in the region, and made getting a raise even more complicated and difficult.
Greater government abandonment of labor standards, greater deregulation
Since the first Aquino government enacted RA 6727 that regionalized wage-setting, labor advocates said, there had been no real minimum wages.
Felipe M. Medalla, a monetary board member of Bangko Sentral ng Pilipinas who formerly worked with the National Economic Development Authority, said in a forum on labor policies this week: “in more than 200 minimum wage rates in the Philippines, only one can be the real minimum. The rest are not.”
With a “floor wage” though that is lower than the current minimum wage, what now is the real minimum wage? Can repressed workers increase their floor wage through a productivity-based pay?
Three months since the wage system and new wage hikes are supposed to be in place, PAMANTIK said, companies have still to establish a productivity incentive committee. This committee is supposed to determine who would get a P12.50 ($0.30) “conditional temporary productivity allowance” as prescribed by Wage Order No. 15.
The experience with two-tier wage system in Southern Tagalog, so far, shows that the new wage system is beginning to slash workers’ wages. Pamantik reports that it has undercut the so-called minimum wages in the region, which they say are already insufficient to begin with.
Next, it has begun to freeze the current minimum wages until these or the floor wage “evolved” and became the same, as Baldoz told Bulatlat.com they would see in five years.
Next, PAMANTIK notes that in the new two-tier wage system, the Aquino government is ceding to individual companies the task of deciding, and granting, pay hikes. If Wage Rationalization Act deregulated wage-fixing per region, per province and per area, the two-tier wage system went further and deregulated wage-fixing per company.
With the creation of the regional wage boards, whenever workers call for a legislated wage hike, the government passes the buck to the regional wage boards. It also had the effect of preventing the unified stand of Filipino workers because they had to deal with their own regional wage boards. For these reasons, the KMU has been calling for the abolition of regional wage boards.
With the two-tier wage system, the government could all the more refuse to legislate an increase in wage hikes. It would even blame workers for their plight by using the false reasoning that workers have low wages because they are not productive enough.
“If a company did not sanction the formation of productivity committee, the workers will get no pay hike,” Urgel said. Also, even within firms or companies, the management can pass the blame on paltry wage hikes to the productivity committee that decided it. Even if the committee based it on the company’s report on productivity.
On the other hand, whether the company forms this committee or not, there is no one to police it, said Urgel. So if a company is not unionized, the workers will find it extremely difficult to even start talking of productivity-based pay hike, he said.
Only three percent of Filipino workers have a union.
No more protection to workers
All in all, the Aquino government’s two-tier wage system is a bane to workers as it effectively lowers the minimum wage and exploits them all the more by making them work harder for a paltry sum called as productivity allowance. But it is a boon to companies as it would allow them to keep wages low while extracting more profits from their workers.
Hermie Marasigan, chairman of Pamantik, at a picket in Calamba, Laguna, Region 4-A. (Photo by Marya Salamat / bulatlat.com)
“What the Regional Wage Boards did was come up with a wage order that will not benefit workers, however which way you look at it,” said Hermie Marasigan, chairman of Pamantik.
The two-tier wage system also adds other avenues for capitalists to take advantage of workers, said Urgel. He explained that experience shows how capitalists use the issue of productivity as a “soft approach” to raising productivity – by getting the union cooperation, for example, in exchange for scant incentives.
Aquino’s two-tier wage system also removed the former coverage, and thus protection, of non-unionized workers under the old system of wage orders, said Urgel. Before, the paltry wage hikes granted by wage orders covered all minimum wage earners. Under the two-tier wage system, a productivity committee is first required before pay hikes can be tackled. In a snap, minimum wage earners are no longer automatically covered by the wage hikes set in the wage order.
This new wage system is highly deceptive, Marasigan warned all workers. He condemned it as “another leap taken by the government to keep all Filipinos’ wages low, and yet, pretend at the same time that they are giving workers a wage hike.”
In truth, there is no wage hike, he said. “The labor department itself has maneuvered to deceive workers with a supposed wage hike whose determination the capitalists hold now even more firmly in their hands.”
With Aquino’s new two-tier wage system, it is clear, said Marasigan, how the Aquino government itself has sabotaged the workers’ demand for substantial wage increase at a time when the working people are being pummeled left and right by price increases.